Many, if not most, churches are constantly looking for qualified, competent, caring, and committed people to help do the work of their ministry. Many, if not most, of these churches have at least one such person hiding in plain sight in their pews at every worship service.
Fifteen-hundred to nearly seventeen-hundred pastors leave the ministry each month. The Hartford Institute for Religious Research estimates there are roughly 350,000 congregations in the United States. Fifth grade division and fourth grade multiplication lead us to the following conclusion: if pastors have been leaving ministry at that rate for just the last 20 years there would be an average of 1 expastor available for every congregation in the country.
I’ve been that guy for almost 5 years now. And I continue to marvel at how difficult it has been to find a new ministry role in the two churches I have attended since leaving the pastorate (by choice, not scandal) after 22 years of preaching, teaching, counseling, and sacrifice. A role that would utilize my gifts and calling, which are without repentance. At 52, I believe I have a few more years of useful service to render in a church context; just not as the head guy. And I see many areas of obvious need in my current church’s ministry where I could help, but have been rebuffed or simply ignored at every offer.
I’m not an ogre. I brush my teeth, comb my hair, and use deodorant every Sunday morning (and the other days of the week, too). I smile, I worship, I give. And then I sigh, and go out to eat with my family. I don’t believe this is a unique experience. I’m convinced it’s a systemic issue that plagues many larger congregations. And I think it’s a shame that the glaring solution might be to attend a smaller church where it would be impossible to hide in plain sight.
So, I’ve made my own “deal with the devil” and decided to remain hidden in plain sight at a church where the word challenges me and the worship invites me into the presence of God. And I have begun to develop ways to fulfill the still rich call on my life by doing ministry outside of my church. I’ve launched a program to heal families and help people who have been rejected, abandoned, forsaken, or abused by a parent, and am contemplating a bible study to teach the basics of the faith to the un-churched and de-churched.
This decade has given us an economy where many have had to retrain and accept positions that underutilize their talents, experiences, and skills in order to make ends meet. Former managers and leaders are now waiting tables or processing phone orders. Doctors from other countries are now driving cabs or working at 7-11. And at church some expastors, like myself, are serving on the parking lot ministry (I’ve done that), or ushering, or running the soundboard or presentation software (I almost did that). To be clear, I am not disparaging any of those ministries. As an example, what I am saying is that when a now defunct small-groups ministry in a church of thousands needs leadership to refocus and re-launch it, that expastor’s gifts and experiences could be better utilized to help in that area of the ministry.
If I could speak to pastors of medium to large sized churches who have untapped clergy resources in their pews I’d offer these 7 suggestions on how to identify and integrate those resources into their ministries.
LOOK. If you’ve prayed for leadership help, or if people in your ministry have been praying for help for you, then expect that God has answered or is answering that prayer and LOOK for the answer. Many times we want the answer to hit us over the head and announce itself, but God often moves more subtly than that and slips the answer right under our nose. There’s a good chance the help you need is hiding in plain sight right there in front of you on Sunday mornings. Like Hagar with the well in Genesis 21 and Abraham with the ram in Genesis 22, your provision may have been there all along and is just waiting to be noticed.
Steve DeWitt
Great read, as I am currently one of yet still ignored, wondering if being ignored has a lot to do with arrogance, I’ve offered my service to anything and all I get is ignored
Earl Middleton
Steve, sorry to hear about your experience. You’re not alone. I pray that you’ll be able to protect your heart to serve despite being ignored. Know that God is always looking at and examining the heart, and in His time He WILL open a door for service. In the meantime, enjoy the break.
Scott Phillips
Thank you for this post (and this site). I have just discovered it last night. I’ve been in this exact situation as an ex-pastor trying to volunteer and being ignored and overlooked. I’ve racked my brain trying to figure it out, you would think a church would like to get free experienced volunteers. I don’t know if it’s ego/pride, sometimes it seems ministry teams are cliques that won’t let anyone in. They’ll let anyone volunteer in kid’s ministry or be a greeter or make coffee but anything else and it’s almost impossible to get plugged in. And forget about raising ideas or suggestions, pastors just see that as a threat to “their” ministry. It puts people like me on the sidelines as someone who just attends and maybe helps in a kids class once a month or something. It’s a shame.
Earl Middleton
Scott, I agree, it IS a shame. I found it helpful to keep in mind that what I can control in the situation is the condition of my heart. I prayed often that God would help me to diligently guard it from bitterness. It took a while, one year to be exact, but I am now about to begin leading a small group in the same church that ignored my offers to help for months. Hang in there.
Steve Simmons
I am one of the few that has come to a church that quickly took me into the fold. They have actually asked me to take on a number of roles (including a future as a pastor of men’s ministries), most of which I have turned down. I get anxious just thinking about serving anywhere outside a small group setting. I’m not sure how long its supposed to take to heal, but after 2 years I am still broken from 13 years of burnout, abuse, public criticism and scandals amongst the pastors I served under.
Earl Middleton
Steve, thanks for the sobering reminder that the grass isn’t always greener on the other side. I pray that full and complete healing and restoration take as long as it needs to take for you.